Before a project goes to bid, owners have to decide how it will be delivered. On most commercial and many larger residential jobs, the choice comes down to two options: hire a general contractor, or bring in a construction manager. Both can produce a good building. They differ in who holds the contracts, how cost is controlled and how involved the owner stays.
How general contracting works
With a general contract, the owner finishes the design with an architect, then hires one contractor to build it. The general contractor holds the subcontracts, buys the materials, runs the site and is responsible for delivering the work described in the drawings.
The owner has one contract and one point of contact. Pricing is usually set against a complete set of drawings, so the owner knows early what the building should cost. Changes after that point are handled through change orders.
This method works well when:
- The drawings are complete or close to it
- The scope is clear and unlikely to shift
- The owner wants a single party responsible for the build
How construction management works
A construction manager is brought in earlier, often while the design is still being developed. The construction manager works on the owner's side to plan the budget and schedule, review drawings for constructability, bid out the trade packages and coordinate the work in the field.
The owner stays closer to the numbers. Cost information is shared as the design develops, and decisions about scope or materials can be made with real pricing in hand instead of after bids come back.
Construction management tends to suit projects where:
- The design is still in progress and the budget needs early input
- Several consultants have to be coordinated
- The owner wants detailed reporting and a say in trade selection
- The work will happen in phases or in an occupied building
Comparing the two
| General contracting | Construction management | |
|---|---|---|
| When the builder joins | After design is complete | During design |
| Who holds the trade contracts | The general contractor | Depends on the agreement, often coordinated by the construction manager on the owner's behalf |
| Pricing | Set against the finished drawings | Developed with the design, with open cost reporting |
| Owner involvement | Lower day to day | Higher, with more decisions shared |
| Best fit | Defined scope, complete drawings | Evolving scope, complex coordination |
Questions to ask before choosing
A few honest answers usually point to the right method. How complete are the drawings? How much do you want to be involved in trade selection and cost decisions? Is the opening date fixed? Will the building stay in use during the work?
If the drawings are done and you want one contract and one number, general contracting is the straightforward route. If the design is still moving, or you want to see how each decision affects cost, construction management gives you more visibility.
Ramas Contracting offers both general contracting and construction management. If you are not sure which fits your project, that conversation is a good place to start.